I took the time to copy this entire article because I think the message is important.
"Canadian pride must not lead to anti-Americanism "
"Well, U.S. President Donald Trump has accomplished one incredible feat since his return to the White House. His threats to impose 25 per cent tariffs on our goods and use “economic force” to turn us into the 51st state have contributed to a surge in Canadian patriotism over the last month. And nowhere is the shift in sentiment more dramatic than in Quebec.
According to an Angus Reid poll published Wednesday, the percentage of respondents across the country professing themselves “very proud” or “proud” to be Canadian leaped to 67 per cent in February from 58 per cent in December. And the percentage of those surveyed who said they have a “deep emotional attachment” to Canada jumped to 59 per cent from 49 per cent over the same period.
And despite our distinct-society status and nationalism, the biggest increase in people sharing these sentiments was in Quebec. The percentage of Quebec respondents reporting pride in Canada climbed to 58 per cent from 45 per cent, up 13 points. And the proportion of Quebecers questioned who expressed profound connection to Canada rose an astonishing 15 points, to 45 per cent from 30 per cent between December and February. Quebec still lags the rest of Canada, but it’s still notable. With his pointless and reckless tariffs — put on hold at the last minute Monday — Trump has achieved the remarkable. He has galvanized divided Canadians to a degree we haven’t seen in ages. And he has reminded Quebecers in particular that there are advantages to being part of the federation, even if nationalist and sovereignist political leaders often claim otherwise.
The Trump effect is also reshaping political fortunes. The federalist Quebec Liberal Party has shot to second place in opinion polls, neck and neck now with the ruling Coalition Avenir Québec at 21 per cent, according to Léger. Although the Parti Québécois is still in the lead at 30 per cent, we’ll see how the prospect of a sovereignty referendum in a first mandate affects voting intentions with the twin menaces of tariffs and a potential U.S. takeover looming. We’ll also see how the message that Canada is broken resonates as the federal and provincial governments work together with rare purpose. Even Quebec Premier François Legault is part of this united front, despite a history of preferring to go it alone.
Perhaps this is a silver lining for Canada to the Trump menace. We have been reminded of our shared values and things we may have been taking for granted. It has fostered a sense of unity. It has forced provinces to set aside their squabbles with each other and Ottawa and come together to tackle issues that have been left to fester for too long. There is talk of breaking down arcane and unproductive internal trade barriers, massive investments in infrastructure, improving productivity and co-operating to secure our vast natural resources for the good of all Canadians. Pivoting away from our biggest trading partner and strongest ally, because the United States may no longer be a reliable neighbour under Trump, will require sacrifices. Yet Canadians are firmly behind such policies — indeed, almost unanimously in some cases — according to the Angus Reid poll.
In the hours after he announced the tariffs Saturday, Canadians reacted swiftly, loudly — and uncharacteristically — when fans at National Hockey League games in Ottawa, Calgary and Toronto booed during the singing of the American anthem. Even since Trump paused the tariffs for 30 days after Canada agreed to appoint a fentanyl czar, the jeering has continued. As typically polite Canadians, we found our voices in high-profile venues to make clear what we think of Trump’s mistreatment. And if there’s a message patriotic Americans will understand, it’s disrespect during The Star-Spangled Banner. But the point has now been made. So we should refrain from taking out our umbrage on ordinary Americans, like peewee hockey players and their families attending a big tournament in Quebec City this weekend. The climate is so tense, Quebec City’s mayor and Quebec’s minister of sport implored the public to mind our manners.
For the one thing Trump’s reign must not do is turn us anti-American. Because that would be un-Canadian. We have every right to be angry at the disregard we’ve been shown since Trump was elected. And we can’t simply shove that aside. But we must not allow ourselves to hate the American people, no matter how much we despise what Trump is doing to us — and to them. It is important to remember that almost half of the country did not vote for Trump. Millions of Americans will suffer from the Trump administration’s moves to try to end birthright citizenship, deport “illegal” immigrants, suspend social programs, dismantle government departments, bypass Congress, seek vengeance on opponents, fire career civil servants, pull out of climate pacts, cast doubt on science, curtail the rights of transgender people, roll back abortion access, end diversity and inclusion programs, give unelected tech billionaire Elon Musk access to America’s bank accounts and taxpayers’ private data, pick fights with neighbours, shred the Constitution, invade other countries — and on and on and on.
Some Americans are living in terror. Some are as irate as we are about what’s happening to their once great country — as is evident from the many letters of apology and sympathy for Canada The Gazette has published this week. Some are still waking up to the reality of what they’ve done. There are plenty of MAGA sycophants, enablers and suck-ups who are helping Trump carry out his destructive agenda with no regard for laws, decency or the Constitution — and they deserve our disdain. But we can’t let them corrupt our cherished Canadian values of kindness, respect and politeness.
So amid our swell of pride and pique of ire, let’s buy Canadian, boycott American, re-evaluate our vacation plans, make jokes, memes and parodies, sing O Canada at the top of our lungs and show our national unity. But let’s not hate.
#Canpoli #Canada #Tariff #BoycottUSA
https://www.montrealgazette.com/opinion/columnists/article738201.html
@SnowshadowII when we talk about being pissed at USA we mean GOP.
@im_mark_aylward Not everyone is as rational as you and I
me.
@im_mark_aylward @SnowshadowII
European perspective: It's not just GOP. The US has allowed itself to become more and more dominated by big business interests over decades. It is a fundamentally flawed society that doesn't effectively protect its citizens with proper regulation of food and farming standards, online privacy, advertising and media standards, drugs, guns, etc; that doesn't provide proper healthcare or a social safety-net, whose basic democratic machinery is dysfunctional and whose main political parties - both of them - are in hock to big business interests because that's the only place they can get sufficient funds to fight elections under the dysfunctional system - and abroad the US has actually always had a terrible record of partisan bullying of small countries, propagating undemocratic coups and worse - Trump might complete the ethnic cleansing of Gaza but Biden certainly facilitated it.
Of course there are lots of good Americans, and we must not allow ourselves to become anti-American in any personal sense - but at the same time, we need to recognise that it's not just the GOP, and Trump is not a one-off, but symptomatic of a deep social malaise.
@GeofCox
Thanks, we are more than aware.
Nearly every tv station is American.
Don't forget we live next door.
@im_mark_aylward
@GeofCox @im_mark_aylward @SnowshadowII I am an American. I hate what my country has become. My avatar means I am a member of #NAFO . I support Ukraine.
@Chakeenah @GeofCox @SnowshadowII I really do sympathize. I think many people believe democracy is simply on election day. But it must be fought for every single day. Keep up the fight!
@Chakeenah Thank you for fighting Russian disinfo, you are facing a huge challenge.
@GeofCox @im_mark_aylward
@im_mark_aylward @SnowshadowII @SnowshadowII go ahead and be pissed at us. I’m pissed at us too.
@BilldeWorde7a @im_mark_aylward
We're angry at the new government, the MAGAs and those who did not vote, not the rest of you. : )
@SnowshadowII @im_mark_aylward i appreciate your nuance and restraint. One of my overwhelming feelings since November is rage that we, as a collective enterprise, are not better. We should be better. But that kind of directionless generalized anger probably isn’t very productive.
@BilldeWorde7a Rage is part of a grief process, maybe you're grieving the loss of democracy.@im_mark_aylward
Such a thoughtful piece, thanks for sharing.
US resident here. It is a nightmare.
Thank you, Canadaians, for being calm stable neighbors.
We have our share of maple magas and hot heads, but the majority are fairly level-headed. We watch and worry with you.
@FallsMom Always!!!
@SnowshadowII Maybe a good dose of global anti-americanism is what this diseased country, not just needs, but deserves.
Thank you for sharing! The people of a country are not their government, and the more fascist it becomes, the fewer people living there are in any kind of support of it. Go ahead and boo. We’re a mess down here.
“It is important to remember that almost half of the country did not vote for Trump.”
Argghhh!
This consistent misrepresentation infuriates me, it gives the big orange baboon a legitimacy he did not earn.
Repeat after me journalists, editorialists, and influencers:
- 22% of American citizens cast a vote for Trump, NOT half
- 78% of Americans did NOT vote for Trump
- 4 out of every 5 people in the US did not vote for Trump
@DavidM_yeg not voting was a vote for Trump.
I understand the sentiment, and yes: not voting accomplished the same thing as a vote for Trump, but it’s also not true that half of America support Trump, which is that the phrase I criticized suggests. And the difference matters, because while I suspect most Trump voters are unlikely to change much, the other 4/5 of the nation *are* all potentially allies which is a very different dynamic.
@DavidM_yeg
"potential allies" There's a good point. Thanks.
(I'm not trying to be dismissive or rude by using short answers, it's just I'm tired because I was on my feet 6 hours -no break-today in and out of the cold; at my age it's a lot. But I am reading your replies and thinking over what you're saying.)
@DavidM_yeg @SnowshadowII Your numbers are misleading, too, because you're apparently comparing the vote to raw population, but a large portion of the population cannot vote at all -- making it look like T-ball had a lower vote than he really did.
Around 212.7 (rounded) million Americans were eligible to vote in Election 2024. Of those, 156,302,318 (63.9%) did. 36.1% of the electorate did not vote AT ALL, for anyone.
T-ball got just under 50% of that vote total, but enough EVs to win.
/2
@DavidM_yeg @SnowshadowII 2/ Harris got slightly less, 48.3% of THOSE WHO VOTED.
By my own estimates (which cannot be proven), Harris should have won. It looks to me like about 80 M people who would likely have voted for her simply didn't vote at all.
My sense is that left-oriented 'purity tests' (The candidate is judged not doctrinally deserving), short-sighted outrage about Gaza, and electoral fatigue were major factors in this.
Apologies in advance: fuck your hairsplitting, you are wrong.
The statement was, “almost half of the country did not vote for Trump”
“The country” includes all the citizens ineligible to vote, including children, the long term migrants and imprisoned or undocumented people.
~ 4 out of every 5 people in the country *did not* vote for Trump.
1/
Collapsing the “country” to people who voted or eligible voters is wrong, factually and morally, and only serves Trump and his gang.
2/f
@DavidM_yeg @SnowshadowII Generally speaking, when professional media use phrases as you quote, that's a rhetorical shortcut meaning not of the whole population, but of those who voted.
Who cares about the numbers now.
I care, when they are used (wittingly or unwittingly) to promote and foster a sense of helplessness and isolation.
@DavidM_yeg
Sorry, I failed to direct my reply to the right person, it wasn't you.
I agree with you.
IMO, it's a waste of time.
@DavidM_yeg @SnowshadowII
and nonvoters outnumbered the D or R votes.
Election was decided by them, as usual
Oh no! I’ve been blocked by a thin skinned reply guy whatever shall I do?
Farewell @wes, I’m afraid I shan’t shed a tear.
Do I hate American people? No, of course not.
Do I hate America? Yes, actually I do, and I think that being anti-American is an important part of being Canadian.
Why? Because the essence of modern America is a growing antithesis and offence to the Canadian aspiration toward respect for others, inclusion, diversity, community, mutual support, tolerance, and egalitarianism.
@DavidM_yeg I agree with you there!!
@SnowshadowII I guess Trump commanded true patriot love in all of you.
We as a group are generally fairly quiet and we don't normally flaunt our flag, but threaten us? Look out, we rally together to defend our country, and Trump did threaten our sovereignty ; we drop the polite Canadian facade and ready ourselves to fight. (look up our brutal and bloodthirsty reputation during WWI.)
@SnowshadowII I don't doubt you for a bit. I've been told too much about the Canadian forces that helped liberating the Netherlands! But I can sing the Canadian anthem, all of it, both in English and in French.