What To Do When People Post Good News or Something Positive:
Favorite or Boost
Leave a nice Comment
Scroll past and do nothing
Literally nothing else!!!
We all know life is hard, and plenty of other bad things exist. Allow people to enjoy their moments not suffocated by fear and anxiety. Hope is important, stop shaming them for it.
This is not to say your feelings and struggles aren't important, of course they are, just use your own platform.
@RickiTarr My mom, who I miss a lot, used to tell me 'If you can't say anything nice, then say nothing at all'. Not everything deserves a snark and I don't think it's naive or silly to sound hopeful with a bit of good news. There's plenty to snark at, but just let folks enjoy any good news that comes along, it's been hard to come by lately.
@RickiTarr Generally favourite, maybe boost, but I mostly only comment if I have something substantive to say.
@Chigaze I just meant any of those things are an option, but hey if you want to do several even better
@RickiTarr Oh, I'm so used to you posting questions for us to answer I just read it that way. :)
@RickiTarr
Thank you for saying this
I am so weary of the Debbie Downers" who flock to every little piece of positive news.
@RickiTarr It sounds fair, but it's asking people to bootstrap. Attention is as good as cash... at keeping people at or below the zero point.
I'm not making any value judgments either way.
@janisf It's asking people to allow other's to share and enjoy their joy.
Recently one of my friends got her name changed officially from her dead name, and she got negative comments not from anti Trans people, but from "Must be Nicers" to the point that she felt bad about posting about it at all.
I feel like this is different than saying things like, No one ever acknowledged me so you shouldn't expect it either. Which I agree would be bootstrapping and shitty.
I do understand the frustration at being at a different place in life than someone else, I just don't think trying to tear down someone else's beautiful moment helps either party.
@RickiTarr Latté, absolutely. I think there's room for a spectrum. Without too much context, it can break a person to see a "friend" buy a third home while scrolling on a break from a homelessness crisis. I think what we might be getting at though is making the internet a terrible place over latté really, really isn't worth it. It hurts everyone.
Yes, we need more joy.
@janisf Yeah, material bragging is shitty, especially if it's excessive! Like if you managed to buy a house, and you did it and overcame a bunch of hardship to do it, let me celebrate that with you, but if you're bragging about a third car or some luxury item, ya basic.
I definitely see both sides of this. I am so happy when I see my friends happy, posting vacation photos of places that are on my bucket list (that I may never see in person, thanks to COVID cautiousness) but I have unfollowed old school acquaintances who seemed to only ever post in a very braggadocious way about their life. I wouldn’t leave resentful comments or try to shame them tho. I just didn’t want to see that kind of materialistic, toxic positivity on my TL constantly.
@KydiaMusic @janisf I agree there, I don't want to see someone's polished version of life, it's why I could never do Facebook or Instagram. Authenticity is better.
@KydiaMusic @RickiTarr What I want to get at is something deeper, maybe uglier than toxic positivity. To try to put it in a nutshell, the culture we're creating when we try to measure up, direct our content at instructing others how to do it, drives a whole lot of teen anxiety (& teen culture repeat ad infinitum), plus angst. Where rdeirecting content to owning our real status to advocate and empower, both for teens and for community effort to reduce poverty, is a different beast.
I’m not sure I follow.
@KydiaMusic @RickiTarr People don't grasp how the contribute to the big picture of what's going on, and they really don't proceed mindfully in their context.
Teens and (for lack of better description) poor people don't need the "motivation" they/we so readily consume, and makes great ad dollars, mostly feeding the already-wealthy. The economic, psyco-social, and internet repercussions of repeated content, patterns, goes deep.
@KydiaMusic @RickiTarr People mean, well, and do well with a little brag, but self-advocacy, and in-group promotion, these days, needs more thought about how it lands in the landscape.
@RickiTarr @janisf My parents, especially my mom, were the "must be nice" sorts. My mom once got really mad when she went shopping with my aunt and the aunt bought six pairs of knee highs to my mom's one. She thought my aunt was deliberately trying to show off how much more money she had. Granted, the aunt in question was a racist shitbag, but using knee highs to brag? C'mon.
@textualdeviance @RickiTarr Racists with a superiority complex? You don't say....
As soon as the psychatrists get off their high horses will start pathologizing the made-up pecking order, and all the heinous behavior that built it, supports it, and perpetuates it.
Sorry your mom had to deal with that. I bet you saw signs of that distress from time to time. Sorry about that, too.
@janisf I think you misunderstood. My aunt (awful as she was) was just buying something she needed, not trying to be petty. My mom (equally awful) still took it as a personal attack.
@textualdeviance OK, got it.
Still, if I'd have been your aunt, I would have found the words to help ameliorate the sentiment. Even if the gesture was unintentional, it doesn't mean she didn't plow through it without acknowledgement.
Misunderstandings can be skirted, we all just need to make a point of seeing them and turning the wheel.
Your mom projected her pain--that's really unfortunate.
@RickiTarr Sometimes I do this. I’m trying to be better about not making jokes about everything. But I still fail occasionally. I’m sorry
@farah Well, you've never done it to me, or if you did it was funny and I didn't care lol
@farah @RickiTarr I think, depending on the joke, that could still qualify as “leave a nice comment.”
Exactly this. Thank you!
Also, as a self-confessed cheerleader can I just add that if you keep an ally standing it works just as well as if you put an opponent down.
You can be nice and do good at the same time.
@RickiTarr are the shitposters and incels taking over this place too? yeesh
@RickiTarr the most positive post of the day
@RickiTarr feed the flickering flame of hope with the kindlings of solace.
If you keep at it long enough, maybe tomorrow might come...who knows?
@RickiTarr I mean even if you are going to be a dick about it eyes on own paper
@RickiTarr
Well, let me both favorite and boost
AND leave a nice comment. That is: if you like this comment
I like hearing good news!
I thought you knew Mastodon culture!
The thing to do is to rip it apart and show how it is not really good news at all.
@RickiTarr @RussSharek
Fine job encouraging good behaviour
I can be bad about this, trying to be better.
@RickiTarr There is one more option. Also post something positive as your next post.
Negative spirals are a thing, but so are positive ones!
So if someone’s post made you feel good, maybe your post can make someone else feel good.
Positivity waves are a good thing.
Good point. Every now and then, someone posts/boosts something that just hits the spot when I'm down. I guess, there may be lots of these toots and I only notice when I'm down.
No matter. When I need them, they magically appear, and I feel better. Not fixed, just better. Sharing something positive myself has the same effect. I feel better!
Mabel says, you should sleep. Sleep is good.
@RickiTarr thank you! We have so little occasions to be happy, we deserve to suck all the joy they bring.